A Prairie Garden Journal    by Dick Meyer

 



To Rake or Not to Rake

That is the Question





      

 

 

 

 

When fall comes to the garden its cold temperatures and brisk winds litter fastidiously manicured lawns and neatly mulched beds with its untidy debris of leaves.   In a society obsessed with imposing its illusion of order on nature’s boisterous and often messy exuberance, cleaning up the recurring debris of autumn has become a cultural imperative.   Leaves are raked up, bagged, and stacked at the curb, to be picked up and carried off to the city landfill—where the dirty and messy process of turning that debris back into the rich life-giving compost can be accomplished out of sight and out of mind.
Some homeowners are quick to clean up fall’s annual debris, and then complain bitterly when the next windy day (which often comes as soon as tomorrow) blows some of the not-as-compulsive-neighbor’s leaves across the street or across the property line. 

 

Previous Articles

April 27, 2006
Crazy Clematis

May 04, 2006
Ornamental Grasses

May 11, 2006
Perennials

May 18, 2006
Herbs

May 25, 2006
Hummingbird Garden Party

June 1, 2006
Gardening with Kids

June 8, 2006
Wildflower Week

June 15th
Shade Garden

June 29
Thumbs, Feathers, Fruit

July 6, 2006
Reading Plants

July 13th
Back to the Oregon Trail

July 20th
Theatre West Garden Walk

July  27th
Notes from the Garden Walk

August 4th
Cereal Killers

August 10th
Grass Hedges

August 17th
Xeriscape Refresher Course

August 24th
Fall is for Planting

August 31st
Tree Roots at the Old Pen

September 7th
Recipe for Enjoying Autumn Landscapes

September 14th
On the Road to Casper

September 15th
Fall is in the Air

October 5th
Seeing Red

Coming Soon
A Prairie Garden Journal
Searchable Archives

 

 

 

 

 Other homeowners dread the chore of cleaning up leaves, waiting as long as possible to begin.  And when the more compulsive neighbor complains, these procrastinators point to a few leaves still clinging to the branches of their trees, as if to say, “No use cleaning up until the mess making is done!”   

Nature is not a fastidious housekeeper.  And for good reason.  From tropical rain forests to arctic tundra, the recurring death of plant tissues and the recycling of those tissues back into life-giving soil elements by complex ecosystems of animals, insects, fungi, and bacteria is an essential aspect of the earth’s plant life.   Scientists were surprised to discover that the most complex plant ecosystems on earth—the tropical rain forests—grow in relatively thin and infertile soils.  What allows a lush rainforest to grow on almost no soil is the rapid rate at which these ecosystems compost the steady stream of plant debris which fall from the forest canopy.   Were the average American homeowner to move into the rainforest and begin bagging up the fallen leaves, his backyard rainforest would likely be reduced to a Sahara Desert-like sand dune within a matter of years.

The continually warm, moist tropical conditions create an almost perfect environment for the insects and microorganisms which perform the “composting” process on the rainforest floor.   The rainforest floor is so efficient that most plant debris is completely converted back into its basic chemical elements within a matter of weeks.  Rainforests are completely dependent upon this continual stream of recycled organic elements.   At first glance that makes the rainforest very fragile ecosystems.  But in reality, the “composting” or element recycling process is such an inherent part of life on earth that, left to themselves, the rainforests are as durable and resilient as any of the earth’s regional ecosystems.

In the great forests and prairies of the earth’s middle latitudes, the recycling of plant debris is no less crucial to the health of forest and prairie ecosystems. 

 

 The annual arrival of winter weather causes a large seasonal shedding of plant debris and also significantly slows the process by which that debris is recycled to a period months and years rather than weeks.  But the limitations of winter weather and unpredictable rainfall at these latitudes also limits the number, size, and diversity of plants which are able to grow in these forest and prairie ecosystems at any given time.  The combination of these factors in the seasonal climates of the middle latitudes allows the forest and prairie ecosystems which grow there to accumulate vast soil “banks” of the organic soil elements.  That’s why the great agricultural regions of the world are found in these middle latitudes. 

Which brings us back to the neighborhood dispute about raking up leaves.   Community standards may come down solidly on the side of the fastidious homeowner—anyone who doesn’t think so has never received a letter from the local code enforcement officer.  But nature (for whatever consolation this is) comes down squarely on the side of the procrastinating neighbor who waits for the last leaf falls before even thinking about raking up leaves—perhaps even waiting until spring. 

The compromise between these two differing approaches to maintaining one’s home landscape can be found in at least understanding that the layer of leaves, stems, and garden debris produced by the arrival of fall weather is more than just an annoying interruption of our otherwise tidy gardening lives.  In nature’s great cycle of life, those unsightly leaves are next year’s flowers, and tomatoes, and butterflies, and robins.  If community sensibilities require that we rake up autumn’s leaves, then nature requires that we bring that debris back into our gardens and landscapes next spring, or perhaps even yet this fall, as compost and mulch.

As for me, well there’s still more than a few leaves clinging to the branches of my trees.

 

                           Back to The Village Garden Center